I’ve been really excited for *Resident Evil: Revelations*. In all the trailers it looks fantastic and that’s why it was the second game Rollo and I checked out at Nintendo World 2011. But unfortunately, it was pretty much the biggest disappoint of the show (so far). That’s not to say it’s the worst game of the show. Nor that it doesn’t have its merits, but going in with such high expectations only served to feel let down as I put down the 3DS and moved on.

The main issue is controls. Perhaps I need a little more practice, or I was simply doing something wrong, but as far as I’m aware controlling the viewpoint is done with the touch screen display, while aiming is done with the right trigger. I guess it’s an interesting approach, but Rollo and I both found that the camera would continually swing in awkward directions, and when an enemy appeared on screen we’d end up shooting their crotch more than anything else as our thumbs lacked the precision to line up a proper shot (or, as I found later, Rollo simply didn’t use the touch screen, which was possible, but still clumsy).

And while the graphics aren’t bad by any means, there’s definitely a roughness to them when you see them up close. It’s probably not even worth mentioning as the environments (which I’ll talk about more in a moment) are quite gorgeous. Jill Valentine, the character you play as through the demo appeared almost as if she was roughly cut out of a piece of paper. I know that’s a weird comparison, but with the 3D all the way up she just seemed disconnected from the entire scene.

There was definitely a tenseness to the gameplay however. At one point you hear a rattling noise, assume its an enemy only for a rat to jump out and scutter away. That may not sound impressive, but it felt like a nice touch. Another example would be a window shattering, wind gushing in and a swarm of bats flying towards you. It may not make you jump in fright, but those small amounts of excitement were appreciated.

At the end of the day I don’t want to say *Resident Evil: Revelations* is bad, but it just left me feeling “meh.” Or, perhaps a better way to put it is that I wouldn’t buy the game in its current stay, or even play it if I was given it for free. Maybe the controls simply have a learning curve, but with most of the other titles working so naturally I don’t feel particularly oblidged to let such a griping slip. That said, the last we’ve heard is that the game is 20% complete, which gives it a ton of time to morph into something far more playable.

  • rod

    Well that’s very disappointing.but like you said it is only 20% complete so I’ll bet it will improve. If it doesn’t i won’t buy it.
    Mercenaries looked fun from the gameplay you put up though.

    By the way was kid icarus good!?!? I’m dieing to hear how you felt about it. Its the game I’m looking forward to the most.

    • sunym

      icarus seems great.the graphic got improved a little.but the way of moving looks a bit weird,which i saw from the ustream

    • rod

      Well I guess that sounds good. I can see what you mean by moving looks weird. I don’t think it’ll affect gameplay though.
      Thanks for the info.

    • retro

      I was really looking forward to this game shame it has so many issues. But hopefully if it’s only 20% complete then there is much space for improvement.

      Hopefully the control scheme just takes some getting used to and it will be adjusted to work better as the game is developed, they may also give us multiple control schemes.

      I’m rather disappointed to hear about the graphics appearance up close, when you talk about roughness are you just talking about regular old jaggies or are you saying the game looks ugly and was that just in 3d mode?

      I’m sure the main character looking like a cardboard cutout probably had a lot more to do with the programming of the game if the environments didn’t also look like cardboard cutouts.

      The main thing is that everything wrong with the game has the potential to be improved and maybe Capcom were a little bit short sighted letting people try out a game that is no where near the later stages of development.

      • David Turnbull

        It was just jaggies. Not bad by any means. Screenshots just made it look a lot smoother though. And I don’t want to make it sound like I hated the game, it was just disappointing. I’m sure a lot of the stuff will be fixed before launch. :)

  • sunym

    don’t know what to say。。。。i’ve been expecting the game for a long time。。。but now i have to consider about whether it is worth getting one

  • nboy22

    Survival Horror games are supposed to feel clumsy; it’s one of their defining traits.

    I’m not saying you’re wrong about the controls being terrible, because I can’t, but I’m just sayin’.

  • http://sylverstone14.tumblr.com Sylverstone Khandr

    Well, it is only 20% done.
    I’d say to give it more time to shine, David.

    Other than that, I had a feeling controls would be an issue this early.

  • Boba2007

    A bit off topic, but you haven’t said anything about Paper Mario 3DS, Mario kart 3DS, Professor Layton, Nitendogs, ect. (most Nintendo made games)
    Are you going to do those tomorrow?

    • David Turnbull

      Most of those games aren’t playable. We’ll check out Nintendogs tomorrow, but I think Professor Layton may be a little too difficult to play with the language barrier.

    • http://gravatar.com/kevinskye Kevinskye

      Theres a gameplay video released on YouTube for Prof layton

  • Hmmm

    RE fans said it was very amazing and controls are the same as Re4
    they said that in 2D It’s better than RE4 and the 3D effect really makes this game unique
    and you don’t need to control using the touch screen
    you made me more excited with the tension part!!

  • gatygun

    controls can be fixed, 3D effect on top of that.

    I just hope the games overal are not paper cuts pasted ontop of the screen. Saw that on a 3D tv a while back ( with video’s ) and it just looking crap.

    Did other games had the same issue?

    Besides that, what did you mean with when looked up close meh?

    You mean the textures became more blurry?

  • Heyy

    Guys, remember how much Metroid Prime Hunters improved? Some of it looked pretty jagged on the demo, but they fixed most of it.

  • STEELFLEX

    this is to bad! I have also been concerned about the controls for metal gear solid 3d because the 3ds doesnt have two joysticks like the ps2 version. what are your guys thoughts?

  • Knuckles

    This hurt me to read I will certainly be waiting for reviews and updates on this game before I consider buying it. What did you think about Mercenaries? I’d like to think that there are at least some awesome Hardcore games with good graphics that I can play day 1 on my 3ds :(

    • David Turnbull

      Mercenaries wasn’t playable unfortunately. I think Street Fighter may be your best bet in terms of hardcore games. Will publish that preview soon hopefully. :)

  • Darth Breh

    Man! Resident Evil is the Whole reason I want a 3DS!! :’(

    • Rej

      Don’t give up hope yet man, as they say, it’s only 20% complete, they can still fix it. This game is also one of the reasons why I like 3DS so much, I really hope they will hear the cries of ours, hehe

  • http://www.steve-Perkins.com Steve Perkins

    I thought the controls were on par with how RE should be done. Yes aiming while looking down the sight so to speak was a bit difficult but I enjoyed everything else about them. RE games usually intentionally lack a large amount of freedom of movement to further make the player feel trapped. No backing up while shooting. I didn’t do the touchscreen controls, but I have to imagine that was rough lol. But as a non RE fan I will be buying this and was very impressed. And yes while the graphics weren’t as good as the touted videos we’ve seen it was still to me the best or second best looking game.

    • David Turnbull

      There’s definitely a chance that it was our own incompetence that made us dislike the controls. Might try it out again tomorrow and update these impressions.

  • Rej

    But some sites say that Revelations’ controls is the same as the console counterparts… And, that’s why Nintendo included the 3d depth slider, so you can adjust it the way you like it, maybe you set it too high that’s why you feel that Jill looked like a paper and is completely out of the game, hmmmm… I wish I’m correct because I’m really looking forward to this game..

  • Lily

    If this game is the reason you want a 3ds, you shouldn’t just give up on it based on a review. I want a 3ds for MGS, even if it receives terrible reviews, I won’t change my mind. Your opinion on the game could be drastically different when you get your turn.

  • DrWatson

    Hi David! Some of the videos were quite blurred when there were fast movements on the screen of the 3DS. This might result from a bad/slow response time of the upper display. When playing, did you, too, observe this kind of effect or was it just due to the camera filming the 3DS? Thanks! DrWatson

  • Adrian

    I love the original RE, the controls are hard and confusing but that makes the game scary ’cause are are always vulnerable.
    Big RE fan, so I’m getting it anyways!

  • _oMeGa_

    Keep in mind that a ton of games for the DS had multiple control schemes.

  • person

    I would like to know what enemies you like zombies or something

  • Robert Salinas

    Hey David, question. How good would you say the graphics are? With the 3d and all? Is it a big step up from ds? Are the graphics smooth like a itouch? And does the 3d really make it look that much better, and make gameplay better?

  • Goly
  • Vash

    I really wanted this game… I guess I’ll have to wait to see if they fix any of these little things.

  • james_bond0014

    personally i hate shooting with the touch screen i hope your right about the multiple control styles :T

  • sammaster9

    i hope that they can fix the controls then. most games dont use the touchscreen and the R button and the abyx buttons, because you have to take your hand off of them to touch the touchscreen

  • Pingback: Megaton ! Nintendo 3DS. - Page 63 - Il Forum ufficiale di Multiplayer.it, con discussioni, sondaggi e le ultime informazioni

  • Fal

    If you guys want a second opinion about RE:R, then here’s a link from andriasang:
    http://www.andriasang.com/e/blog/2011/01/09/resident_evil_revelations_impressions/

  • wohoo

    http://www.andriasang.com/e/blog/2011/01/09/resident_evil_revelations_impressions/

    Here’s a link for those who are a bit disappointed with this article. And they say is one of the most impressive and steal the show!!

    Maybe David is not really into resident evil series or the 3DS he’s playing is broken..

    • Sputtid

      Is it possible that David isn’t familiar with ya good olde Resident Evil controls? They are meant to be clunky.That might explain bad impressions.

  • Renato

    It sounds like you’re a noob in horror games.

    • wraith

      Wow the man gives his honest impression of a game and because its not as wonderful as some had thought/hoped they think it must be the reviewer and start with the noob calling… Thanks david for honestly giving us your thoughts on this game.

  • The Hero of Time

    this games not coming out anytime soon, so im sure their going to fix most of those small problems. it sounds alot like RE4 to me which isnt a bad thing :D David are there actual zombies or just those wierd creature things?